National Science Foundation considers shuttering Arecibo

Please consider donating to Behind the Black, by giving either a one-time contribution or a regular subscription, as outlined in the tip jar to the right. Your support will allow me to continue covering science and culture as I have for the past twenty years, independent and free from any outside influence.

Faced with tight budgets, the National Science Foundation (NSF) is considering several options for the future operation of the Arecibo Observatory, the world’s largest single radio telescope dish, including its complete removal.

[T]he NSF could mothball the site, shutting it down in such a way that it could restart (sometime in the future). Or it could dismantle the telescope altogether and restore the area to its natural state, as required by law if the agency fully divests itself of the observatory and closes it. Previous studies have said such a process could cost around $100 million—more than a decade’s worth of its current funding for telescope operations. Jim Ulvestad, director of the NSF Division of Astronomical Sciences, says the agency is still investigating, not concluding. “No alternative has been selected at this juncture,” he says. And much consideration will go into the final financial decision, whatever it may be. Some outside the agency see writing on the wall. “NSF is dead serious about offloading Arecibo funding to someone else—anyone else,” says Ellen Howell, a former staff scientist at Arecibo and now a faculty member at the Lunar and Planetary Laboratory (LPL) in Tucson, Arizona.

The article spends a lot of time talking about how wonderful Arecibo is, but never tells us how many astronomers actually demand to use it. Is it oversubscribed, like Hubble, where five times the number of astronomers request time than can be handled, or does it often sit unused because not enough astronomers require its use? NSF and the government do not have unlimited funds, and need to focus their spending where the demand is. If Arecibo is not in demand, then they are wise to consider closing it, or handing it off to someone who wants it.


  • ivenho

    Seems like a read somewhere that China is currently constructing an even larger radio telescope. If true, that may serve either as an impetus to reinvigorate Arecibo, or as a pretext to mothball it, potentially shifting the cost (and prestige) of future radio astronomy to the Chinese.

  • I remember a few years ago the Bad Astronomer wrote this breathless blog post about how great Arecibo and how unfair it was that there should be a limited budget. At which point it shitted to talking about how Republicans don’t believe in science how evil George Bush was.

    I’m sure if i looked through most of main stream media coverage it would mention it was used in a Goldeneye and how Republicans don’t believe in funding Science with no mention that Obama is Democrat or fact he even President. Because narrative…

  • LocalFluff

    Arecibo has been outsourced to China. Bigger, better, cheaper. Hopefully their astronomers are as smart. But this is an opportunity to donate Arecibo to SETI! They have a hundred million dollar donation now, they could afford to run it for their purposes. Shostak would eat his clothes even thinking this thought. (I bet there are aliens out there trying to signal us like a ship in havoc, because Shostak says so and he should know since he’s obviously one of’em).

    The Chinese 500 meter telescope is planned to take first light this year.
    They just need a James Bond movie to popularize it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *