Please consider donating to Behind the Black, by giving either a one-time contribution or a regular subscription, as outlined in the tip jar to the right or below. Your support will allow me to continue covering science and culture as I have for the past twenty years, independent and free from any outside influence.
Rather than publish another weekly update on the fascist culture that presently dominates many American campuses, I thought I would look back on the year and compile a list of all the colleges I reported where acts of oppression or the silencing of free speech were carried out by the administration, facility, or student body.
There were many ways I could have compiled this list. In the end, I decided to list the colleges alphabetically by state, and then sort the states into three groups, based on how those states voted in the past two presidential elections. States that voted Democratic or Republican both times are grouped together as either Democratic- or Republican-dominated. States that flipped from one party to the other (all flipping Republican, by the way) were listed as battleground states. If a college had more than oppressive incident during the year the number of incidents is indicated in parenthesis.
Because the list is so long, I have placed it, as well my analysis of it, below the fold. Before you read on, make sure you scan down take a look at the list of colleges itself.
We can garner several things from this list. First, though the list doesn’t illustrate this, I must note that almost every college shown marks a moment when leftist members of an administration, facility, or student body acted to squelch the free speech rights of a conservative. Nor do I think this is because of bias on my part. From the beginning I have recognized the possibility that I might unfairly only report oppressive incidents committed by the left, and have tried to avoid that. Unfortunately, despite my sincere effort to report incidents where conservatives tried to silence liberals, during the whole year I only came across one event where a conservative college acted to shut down a dissenting liberal speaker. I admit that I might have missed a few, but even if I did I do not think this would change the overall pattern. 2017 was a year in which the left decided that it was acceptable to act like fascist thugs and do whatever they could to shut down the free speech of opposing points of view.
Second, while the majority of universities behaving oppressively appear to be in the Democratic states, there are also appear to be plenty of oppressive universities in Republican regions. Yet, there was only one case where a college acted to silence someone who appeared to be liberal. I suspect therefore that the wide regional spread of oppressive colleges is not because this fascist behavior is favored across the entire political spectrum, but because almost the entire academic community is strongly dominated by the left, even in conservative regions, and it is today’s left that is most attached to the idea that all dissent must be silenced.
Third, the list strongly indicates that the west coast and the northeast are regions that have become especially hostile to free speech and dissent. The incidents of oppression were more concentrated in colleges in these regions than anywhere else in the country. In this case I believe (partly from personal experience having lived most of my life in the liberal northeast) this is because the overall cultures in these regions has become especially totalitarian. It isn’t just the colleges where dissent is no longer tolerated. It is the entire region. Woe to anyone who takes the chance in these places to walk around wearing a “Make America Great Again” hat, or put up Republican campaign signs in their front yards.
Fourth, this list argues strongly that all financial support to these universities needs to be questioned, or eliminated entirely. It is unconscionable for public money to be used to support this kind of behavior. Any state, such as California, Washington, Oregon, and New York, that has not done anything to address this behavior at their public universities demonstrates that they are actually a part of the problem.
Finally, and most important, parents and children should strongly question whether these universities are good places to get a good liberal arts education. My own conclusion, not merely from this list but from my own personal experiences teaching and working within the academic community at several colleges during the past few decades, says that every single one of these colleges should be avoided, like the plague.
University of California-Berkeley (13)
University of California-San Diego
University of California-Merced
University of California-Los Angeles (5)
University of California-Riverside
University of California-Santa Cruz (2)
University of California-Irvine
University of California-Davis
Stanford University (3)
California State University-Fresno (2)
Loyola Marymount University
University of Colorado-Colorado Springs
University of Colorado-Boulder (2)
University of Northern Colorado
University of Connecticut
Quinebaug Valley Community College
Yale University, Connecticut
District of Columbia
George Washington University
American University (2)
University of Hawaii
Tufts University (2)
Brandeis University (2)
University of Massachusetts
Wartburg College (2)
Concordia College, Moorhead
St. Olaf College
University of Nevada-Reno
Keene Stage College
Princeton University (2)
Columbia University (4)
New York University
University of Oregon
Portland State University
Brown University, Rhode Island (2)
Middlebury College, Connecticut
University of Virginia
College of William and Mary
Virginia Commonwealth University
Evergreen State College (6)
Western Washington University
Seattle University School of Law
Florida State University
University of Florida
University of Michigan
Drexel University (2)
University of Wisconsin-Madison (2)
Arizona State University
University of Arizona
University of Arkansas
University of Georgia
Boise State University
University of Iowa
Northern Kentucky University
University of Montana
Duke Divinity School
University of Oklahoma
Clemson University, South Carolina
South Dakota State University
University of Tennessee (2)
Northwest Vista College
Texas State University
University of Texas-San Antonio
Texas Southern University
Southern Methodist University