Elon Musk confirms that on future Falcon 9 launches they will do tests of a powered return of the first stage.

A quick holiday fund-raising campaign for Behind the Black!
Scroll down to read this post.
In past years I have managed to avoid asking for donations for Behind the Black during the holiday season. My finances however now compel me to do a short one-week fund-raiser, from November 11 to November 17.
I do not use Twitter for ethical reasons, which I have been told cuts down on traffic to the website. So be it. Furthermore, Facebook has clearly acted in the past two years to limit traffic to Behind the Black, almost certainly for political reasons. So be this as well. Finally, I do not post outside ads, as I have found them annoying to my readers and not that profitable to me.


Therefore, I need to ask for the direct support from my readers. If you like what I do here, please consider contributing, either by making a one-time donation or a monthly subscription, as indicated in the tip jar below.


Regular readers can support Behind The Black with a contribution via paypal:

Or with a subscription with regular donations from your Paypal or credit card account:

If Paypal doesn't work for you, you can support Behind The Black directly by sending your donation by check, payable to Robert Zimmerman, to
Behind The Black
c/o Robert Zimmerman
P.O.Box 1262
Cortaro, AZ 85652


Or you could consider purchasing one of my books, as indicated in the boxes scattered throughout the website. My histories of space exploration are award-winning and are aimed for the general public. All are page-turners, and all not only tell the story of the beginning of the human exploration of space, they also help explain why we are where we are today. And I also have a science fiction book available, Pioneer, which tells its own exciting story while trying to predict what life in space will be like two hundred years in the future.


Note that for this week only I am also having a sale on the purchase of the last 20 hardbacks of Leaving Earth. (Click on the link for more information about the book, which was endorsed by Arthur C. Clarke himself!) This award-winning out-of-print book is now only available as an ebook, but I still have a handful of hardbacks available, normally for sale for $70 plus $5 shipping. For this week only you can buy them, personally autographed by me, for $50 plus $5 shipping! Just send me a check, payable to Robert Zimmerman, to the address above, with a note saying that the money is for the Leaving Earth hardback.


Please consider donating. Your help will make it possible for me to continue to be an independent reporter in the field of space, science, technology, and culture.

The competition heats up: Elon Musk confirms that on future Falcon 9 launches they will do tests of a powered return of the first stage.

For the upcoming flight, after stage separation the first stage booster will do a burn to slow it down and then a second burn just before it reaches the water. In subsequent flights they will continue these over-water tests. He repeatedly emphasized that he expects several failures before they learn how to do it right. If all goes well with the over-water tests, they will fly back to launch site and land propulsively. He expects this could happen by mid-2014.

These tests are an extension of the Grasshopper tests, only this time they will take place during an actual launch.



  • That’s a very aggressive schedule. Recall that Virgin Galactic was supposed to start revenue operations last year, and they’ve yet to mate the powerplant with the airframe, much less test and certify the vehicle. If Space X achieves recoverability and re-use of the first stage in the next 18 months, it will still be an impressive feat. I’d think they’re probably 3 – 5 years from a recoverable (1st & 2nd stage) man-rated launcher. Chapeau to Mr. Musk and his team for making the effort.

  • If they are able to recover the first stage of a Falcon 9, this will put them in a position to offer the lowest cost launcher by an even greater margin. But even if they aren’t able to quite make it, they could still use them on a Falcon Heavy launch where, with cross-feeding, the lateral core stages separate earlier than on a Falcon 9. This would make it likely that those lateral boosters would be able to be recovered since they are traveling slower at separation. If they were to achieve that, then they would be able to recover two out of four portions of their rocket and nearly 2/3rds of their engines. This would drive down their already low cost by something like 50%. At the same time, two Falcon Heavy payloads docked in LEO mass nearly the same thing as the Saturn V.

    SpaceX is doing the most to really break open space. I wish them success.

  • Dick Eagleson

    I didn’t get to see the live feed of the press conference where Elon made his remarks about first stage recovery tests and can’t seem to find it archived anywhere either (any assistance in this regard from other readers would be greatly appreciated). Failing that, perhaps someone who saw the thing can tell me what the context of “next” was when Elon said SpaceX would be attempting a recovery-type flight profile for the F9 v1.1 first stage on the “next” flight. In my current condition of ignorance, I see three meanings of “next” as plausible. One is the next Commercial Resupply flight to ISS, but this is currently scheduled for Nov. 28. That seems like a long time to wait and it would actually be the fifth scheduled launch of the new v1.1 vehicle. Two, if the planned first stage recovery experiments are going to be conducted only on launches from Cape Canaveral, he might have meant the next F9 mission launched from there. This is the SES-8 GEO comsat scheduled for early July launch. This would be SpaceX’s second v1.1 launch and first GEO mission. Three – and what I hope he meant – is the actual first v1.1 launch of the CASSIOPE satellite into a high-inclination orbit from Vandenberg AFB, currently scheduled for June 18. If Elon plans to conduct first stage recovery tests on every upcoming F9 mission until success is achieved, the current SpaceX launch schedule shows that he has as many as five opportunities before the end of this year; four if only Canaveral launches count. Anybody out there have inside scoop that would pin this testing thing down for me?

  • My impression of his remarks is that once they begin using the upgraded Merlin engine they intend to begin tests. Musk was not clear on which launches, but it seemed pretty clear that they want to take advantage of every launch opportunity to test this technology.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *