New data says interstellar Comet 3I/Atlas IS different from comets in our solar system
Using spectroscopic data from the ALMA telescope in Chile, astronomers have determined that interstellar comet 3I/Atlas is enriched in deuterium (sometimes called “heavy water”), with quantities as much as 30 times that found in ordinary solar system comets and 40 times that found in Earth’s oceans.
You can read the peer-reviewed paper here. From its abstract:
3I/ATLAS shows a deuterium enrichment exceeding Earth’s ocean value by more than a factor of about 40 and typical Solar System cometary values by more than a factor of about 30. The elevated deuterium enrichment points to water that formed under colder, less irradiated conditions and from less thermally processed material, consistent with an origin in a planetary system that formed under different physical and chemical conditions than our own.
In other words, the conditions in which Comet 3I/Atlas’ solar system formed were very different from those when our own solar system formed.
This conclusion is wonderful, but it raises more questions than it answers. Since we do not know how old the comet is, nor do we really know where it came from, there is little else we can glean from this result, other than it proves the conditions when solar systems form can vary widely.
Using spectroscopic data from the ALMA telescope in Chile, astronomers have determined that interstellar comet 3I/Atlas is enriched in deuterium (sometimes called “heavy water”), with quantities as much as 30 times that found in ordinary solar system comets and 40 times that found in Earth’s oceans.
You can read the peer-reviewed paper here. From its abstract:
3I/ATLAS shows a deuterium enrichment exceeding Earth’s ocean value by more than a factor of about 40 and typical Solar System cometary values by more than a factor of about 30. The elevated deuterium enrichment points to water that formed under colder, less irradiated conditions and from less thermally processed material, consistent with an origin in a planetary system that formed under different physical and chemical conditions than our own.
In other words, the conditions in which Comet 3I/Atlas’ solar system formed were very different from those when our own solar system formed.
This conclusion is wonderful, but it raises more questions than it answers. Since we do not know how old the comet is, nor do we really know where it came from, there is little else we can glean from this result, other than it proves the conditions when solar systems form can vary widely.












