Capitalism in space: During this week’s 52nd Lunar and Planetary Science Conference, one poster [pdf] caught my eye as something significant. It was titled “SpaceX Starship Landing Sites on Mars.” The map to the right is figure 1 from that poster, annotated slightly by me based my earlier stories about SpaceX’s use of the high resolution camera on Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter (MRO) to research potential Martian landing sites for its Starship spacecraft. The stars indicate MRO images, most of which were described and linked to in my last major post about this SpaceX effort in November 2019.
The red spots covering some stars are the big story: SpaceX has narrowed its choice for its Starship landing site to four prime locations (indicated by the bright red spots) and three backup locations (indicated by the dark red spots). The images under the red spots numbered 2, 4, and 6 were linked to in my November 2019 post. The images under red spots marked by a “D” are earlier images taken by MRO when SpaceX was researching a potential Dragon landing site. The images under red spots labeled 1P and MRO are subsequent images taken by MRO since November 2019, with the 1P image previously linked to in a post in April 2020 entitled “The icy Phlegra Mountains: Mars’ future second city.”
The poster outlined why the prime candidate sites — PM1, EM16, AP1, and AP9 — were favored. For example, PM-1 in the Phlegra Mountains “…has the lowest latitude and elevation of the group, a clear association with LDAs [lobate debris aprons that resemble glacial features], well developed polygons, and has the highest SWIM [Subsurface Water Ice Mapping] score for geomorphic indicators of ice.”
EM 16 “…has a clear association with an LDA with nearby brain terrain and the strongest radar return for shallow ice and the highest combined SWIM score.”
AP1 “…appears to be the safest site and has a moderate combined SWIM score for ice.”
AP9 “…has the thickest ice from radar returns and geomorphology indicating shallow ice. It has the highest combined SWIM score for ice, but appears slightly rocky and rough.”
Below the fold are images, rotated, cropped, and reduced to post here, of the four primary landing sites, as well as links to the full images of all four plus the three back-up sites (AP8, EM15, and PM7).
For full images, PM1 can be found here, EM16 can be found here.
These first two sites above are located in the Phlegra and Erebus Mountains, respectively. Thus, there are significant topographical features nearby. Moreover, both sites would land Starship near or on features that resemble glaciers.
These second two sites above are both located in the flat somewhat featureless northern lowland plains dubbed Arcadia Planitia. Though there are no obvious glacial features, there is strong evidence that an ice layer is very close to the surface, as indicated by the bright spots in craters. Radar data has also suggested that there is ample water ice only a few feet underground.
There is a great deal more research necessary before a final choice can be made. As the poster noted:
To further assess these landing sites’ suitability for human missions and persistent human presence on Mars, additional site characteristics should be considered. For each location these include: further understanding the location and safety of the landing sites, the extent and characteristics of the ice deposits, the methods and difficulty by which the ice could be extracted for in situ resource utilization, the proximity and trafficability to the landing site(s), and the near-surface materials that could be utilized for the outpost.
All this data must also tell them whether a rocket ship can safely land at any of these locations, considering that it is thought that ice is so prevalent and close to the surface. It would not do for the ground to unevenly sublimate away from the rocket engine exhaust and cause the rocket to tilt over.
One last note: Back in 2019, when the MRO science team took the first series of images, they labeled each a “candidate landings site” for SpaceX’s Starship. When I posted the first news report in August 2019 on these images the story was quickly picked up by numerous other news organizations, riding on the research I had done.
All well and good. Most news organizations credited me for breaking the story. All, however, including myself, could get little comment from SpaceX about what the company’s intentions were in connection with the images.
The publicity however apparently caused the science team and SpaceX to rethink how they labeled the images.
Since then I have posted many cool images of a number of MRO high resolution photos throughout this region, including the Phlegra and Erebus Mountains as well as Arcadia Planitia, all of which were given geologically descriptive labels that made no mention of Starship. Based on this poster, it appears that some of those images that I had posted were still part of the company’s campaign to pin down a landing site, only they were no longer identifying them as part of that campaign.
Thus, from now on any images from MRO that covers these seven locations are going to be posted here on Behind the Black, in an effort to find out what they are learning about each site, as they learn it. Stay tuned!
From the press release: From the moment he is handed a possibility of making the first alien contact, Saunders Maxwell decides he will do it, even if doing so takes him through hell and back.
Unfortunately, that is exactly where that journey takes him. The vision that Zimmerman paints of vibrant human colonies on the Moon, Mars, the asteroids, and beyond, indomitably fighting the harsh lifeless environment of space to build new societies, captures perfectly the emerging space race we see today. He also captures in Pioneer the heart of the human spirit, willing to push forward no matter the odds, no matter the cost. It is that spirit that will make the exploration of the heavens possible, forever, into the never-ending future. Available everywhere for $3.99 (before discount) at amazon, Barnes & Noble, all ebook vendors, or direct from the ebook publisher, ebookit. And if you buy it from ebookit you don't support the big tech companies and I get a bigger cut much sooner.