How the Republican Party might break-up

Please consider donating to Behind the Black, by giving either a one-time contribution or a regular subscription, as outlined in the tip jar to the right. Your support will allow me to continue covering science and culture as I have for the past twenty years, independent and free from any outside influence.

Devin Nunes (R-California), a establishment Republican supporting Kevin McCarthy (R-California) for House Speaker, said today that any Republicans who don’t vote for McCarthy should be kicked out of the party.

Nunes is talking about the final House-wide vote for Speaker. First the Republicans vote in private among themselves, picking their nominee. McCarthy is expected to easily win that vote. Then the entire House votes. Some conservatives are threatening to not vote for McCarthy in that House-wide vote in order to extract greater influence over the entire party. Nunes wants them ejected from the party if they do that.

I have also read another story, the link to which I can’t find now, where establishment Republicans want to codify what Nunes is saying, so that any Republican who voted against McCarthy in the final vote would be kicked out of the party. If this happens, then we might very well see the Republican Party split, something that I increasingly see as a possibility. Right now the party is trying to be too big a tent, including conservatives and many moderate Democrats who find the modern Democratic Party unacceptable. (This is one reason why the Republican presidential field is so large.)

Should the party split, we might also eventually see the withering away of the Democratic Party, which today is very corrupt and far too leftwing for most Americans. If the Republicans split into conservative and moderate wings, many of those disenchanted Democrats would move to the moderate Republican faction. The result would be to cut off the corrupt modern Democratic Party from the reins of power.

I am of course being hopeful and naively optimistic. A more likely scenario would be for the Republican Party to split in such a way that the unified Democrats, still corrupt, would take over.


  • Steve

    You’re probably right, the left seems to hold far more sway over the DNC than the right has ever held with the RNC.

    Still it would be nice to see a party that actually does what it says and says what it does for a change….

  • Edward

    Obviously, if a vote in an election is something that can have such dire consequences, then it is not the free election that the Republican Party is supposed to stand for.

    I think that an even more likely scenario is that the Republican Party eventually joins with the Democrat Party, as their policies have been moving in the same direction as the Democrats, except that they lag by a couple of years (a few years ago, they lagged by about five years, so they are rapidly catching up). The current Republican leadership is currently behaving as the Democrat leadership behaved only a couple of years ago. This “think my way or you’re not one of us” mentality is definitely Democratic.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *