The murder rate on U.S. islands with strict gun laws

To read this post please scroll down.

Readers! A November fund-raising drive!

It is unfortunately time for another November fund-raising campaign to support my work here at Behind the Black. I really dislike doing these, but 2025 is so far turning out to be a very poor year for donations and subscriptions, the worst since 2020. I very much need your support for this webpage to survive.

And I think I provide real value. Fifteen years ago I said SLS was garbage and should be cancelled. Almost a decade ago I said Orion was a lie and a bad idea. As early as 1998, long before almost anyone else, I predicted in my first book, Genesis: The Story of Apollo 8, that private enterprise and freedom would conquer the solar system, not government. Very early in the COVID panic and continuing throughout I noted that every policy put forth by the government (masks, social distancing, lockdowns, jab mandates) was wrong, misguided, and did more harm than good. In planetary science, while everyone else in the media still thinks Mars has no water, I have been reporting the real results from the orbiters now for more than five years, that Mars is in fact a planet largely covered with ice.

I could continue with numerous other examples. If you want to know what others will discover a decade hence, read what I write here at Behind the Black. And if you read my most recent book, Conscious Choice, you will find out what is going to happen in space in the next century.

This last claim might sound like hubris on my part, but I base it on my overall track record.

So please consider donating or subscribing to Behind the Black, either by giving a one-time contribution or a regular subscription. I could really use the support at this time. There are five ways of doing so:

1. Zelle: This is the only internet method that charges no fees. All you have to do is use the Zelle link at your internet bank and give my name and email address (zimmerman at nasw dot org). What you donate is what I get.

2. Patreon: Go to my website there and pick one of five monthly subscription amounts, or by making a one-time donation. Takes about a 10% cut.

3. A Paypal Donation or subscription, which takes about a 15% cut:

4. Donate by check. I get whatever you donate. Make the check payable to Robert Zimmerman and mail it to

Behind The Black
c/o Robert Zimmerman
P.O.Box 1262
Cortaro, AZ 85652

You can also support me by buying one of my books, as noted in the boxes interspersed throughout the webpage or shown in the menu above.

December 5, 2015 9:32 am Robert Zimmerman

A comparison of the murder rate on U.S. islands that have very strict gun control laws with the average U.S. murder rate finds that gun control has no effect on reducing violence, and in fact might help increase it.

The article finds that the Virgin Islands and Puerto Rico have far more murders per person than the U.S., while Hawaii has less. The research does demonstrate, however, that the argument used by places like Chicago, New York, and Washington, DC (that the access to guns in nearby communities causes their gun laws to fail) is bogus. It doesn’t matter if guns are available nearby, as shown above. Instead, as the author correctly notes,

A major problem with trying to lower murder rates with gun laws aimed at restricting the entire population’s access to firearms is that only a tiny number of guns are needed to supply those involved in violent crime. From an economic perspective, it does not matter much if you attempt to fill a bucket from a small pond or an ocean; filling the bucket is easy in either case.

3 comments

hondo
December 5, 2015 at 2:53 pm
Thanks Bob for referencing Dean Weingarten – he does great work in the cause of the 2nd Amendment.

Homicide is a cultural thing – the tools are irrelevant (especially to the victim).
CVA
December 6, 2015 at 8:16 am
Hondo, rather…homicide is lack of culture thing?
Cotour
December 6, 2015 at 5:18 pm
I think the take away from this article and the statistics it sites again points to the glaring difference between the locations with the highest murders per 100K people and the lowest, CULTURE. Should Americans settle and surrender their freedoms for an invasion of garbage culture where human life is worth much less? Low standards is no standards, and who wants to live in a hybrid garbage culture?

This article from Salon makes the argument that the metric should be safety and not freedom and to finally jettison the old and inapplicable to modern existence second amendment.

http://www.salon.com/2015/12/04/the_second_amendment_must_go_we_ban_lawn_darts_its_time_to_ban_guns/

He proposes to cast aside the master design and change the Constitution 1. because it is changeable and 2. he proposes to surrender freedom for “safety” and of course he begins his piece citing how many children are killed in accidents in their cribs. I get the correlation between death caused by an accident or poor design of a crib / product and passing law to mitigate it, but his real story logic leverage was that he was able to work the death of children and “protecting” them (ala Bill Clinton) into his piece and equate changing the second amendment with it. Thats is a big set up fail for me, comparing apples and bananas. Too bad all tyranny was not perpetrated with the use of cribs, then his point would have had more sustainable weight.

*A man walks into a bank and announces “this is a stick up” as he cocks the crib he dragged into the bank with him.

*Fidel Castro and his band of revolutionaries climb down from the mountains of Cuba dragging their cribs through the streets of Havana to take control from Batista.

See , it really does not work that well.

The murder rate on U.S. islands with strict gun laws

3 comments

Leave a Reply