What AI thinks Thanksgiving looked like

The first Thanksgiving by Jean Louis Gerome Ferris
Doug Ross did something truly fascinating today, to mark Thanksgiving:
“Please create a detailed painting of the first Thanksgiving in America”.
That was the prompt I gave ten of the most popular image-generating AI models. Let’s compare. And throw your reactions in the comments. Happy Thanksgiving to all!
#1 – Nano-Banana-Pro (Google):
#2 – GPT-Image-1 (OpenAI):
#3 – Imagen-4-Ultra (Google):
#4 – FLUX-2-Flex (Black Forest Labs):
#5 – Dreamina-3.1 (ByteDance – China):
#6 – Ideogram-v3 (FAL):
#7 – Qwen-Image-20B (China):
#8 – Amazon-Nova-Canvas (AWS):
#9 – Phoenix-1.0 (Leonardo Ai):
#10 – Flux-Kontext-Max (Black Forest Labs):
Go to the link and check them out. None of them are great art. All illustrate the vapidness of AI and its inability to be truly creative (all basically copy older paintings like Ferris’s to the right). But each tells you something about its AI. For example, though some of these AIs (Google’s) have largely corrected the DEI aspects of their AI, that insisted on making every Founding Father black, they haven’t all gotten it right.
Enjoy! This is one entertaining way to spend a few minutes on Thanksgiving while you wait for the turkey to cook.

The first Thanksgiving by Jean Louis Gerome Ferris
Doug Ross did something truly fascinating today, to mark Thanksgiving:
“Please create a detailed painting of the first Thanksgiving in America”.
That was the prompt I gave ten of the most popular image-generating AI models. Let’s compare. And throw your reactions in the comments. Happy Thanksgiving to all!
#1 – Nano-Banana-Pro (Google):
#2 – GPT-Image-1 (OpenAI):
#3 – Imagen-4-Ultra (Google):
#4 – FLUX-2-Flex (Black Forest Labs):
#5 – Dreamina-3.1 (ByteDance – China):
#6 – Ideogram-v3 (FAL):
#7 – Qwen-Image-20B (China):
#8 – Amazon-Nova-Canvas (AWS):
#9 – Phoenix-1.0 (Leonardo Ai):
#10 – Flux-Kontext-Max (Black Forest Labs):
Go to the link and check them out. None of them are great art. All illustrate the vapidness of AI and its inability to be truly creative (all basically copy older paintings like Ferris’s to the right). But each tells you something about its AI. For example, though some of these AIs (Google’s) have largely corrected the DEI aspects of their AI, that insisted on making every Founding Father black, they haven’t all gotten it right.
Enjoy! This is one entertaining way to spend a few minutes on Thanksgiving while you wait for the turkey to cook.















